Rev. Father Joseph Plunkett, 1860-1863 Rev. Father Thomas Oulette, S.J., 1864-1865 Rev. Father Matthew O'Keefe, 1865-1870 Rev. Father John J. Doherty, 1871-1872 Rev. Father Henry J. Cutler, 1872-1873 Rev. Father John P. Hagan, 1873-1875 Rev. Father Patrick J. Hasty, 1875-1877 Rev. Father Thomas J. Murray, 1877-1886 Rev. Father Thomas J. Mercer, 1886-1901 Rev. Father William A. O'Hara, 1901 Rev. Father William A. Fallon, 1901-1908 Rev. Father Thomas J. Wilson, 1908-1920 Rev. Father William T. Whearty, 1920-1921 Rev. Father William A. Gill, 1921-1933 Rev. Father Richard B. Washington, 1933-1936 Rev. Father Joseph F. Govaert, 1936-1940 Rev. Father Rev. Father John Igoe, 1940-1950 Rev. Father Julius O. Schmidhauser, 1950-1958 Rev. Father John F. McMahon, 1959-1961 Rev. Father John J. Riordan, 1961-1968 Rev. Father Robert J. McEleney, 1968-1971 Rev. Father Raymond E. Schantz, 1971-1975 Rev. Father Leonard Cordier, 1975-1977 Rev. Father Eugene Daigle, 1977-1979 Rev. Father Charles W. Brickner, O. Praem, 1979-1990 Rev. Father Joseph L. Clark, 1990-2003 Rev. Father Peter M. Creed, 2003-2006 Rev. Father Anthony Morris, CSsR, 2006-2008 Rev. Father Peter E. Sousa, CSsR, 2008-2011
Rev. Monsignor Walter C. Barrett, Jr., 2011- Present